| This time of year, we are often asked in the clinic about
helmets while skiing/snowboarding. Our recommendation is for people
to wear helmets while participating in these activities. Please read
on for more information on both sides of the debate. |
 |
Canadian researchers found that the occurrence of both spinal cord and
traumatic brain injury appears to be increasing worldwide. They reported that
these increased injury rates coincide with an increase and acceptance of higher
speeds on the slopes and more acrobatic maneuvers, such as jumping and twists.
They also reported that wearing a helmet can reduce the risk of head injury by
up to 60 percent and highly recommend helmets for skiers and boarders.
What is a concussion?
A concussion is a traumatic injury to the brain that alters mental status or
causes other symptoms. A concussion is typically caused by a severe head trauma
where the brain moves violently within the skull so that brain cells all fire at
once, much like a seizure.
Many people assume they do not have a concussion if they
have not lost consciousness. However, significant injury can occur without
losing consciousness at all. Football players often say "I just got my bell
rung" when a blow to the head causes ringing in the ears, but those symptoms are
often consistent with concussion.
If left undiagnosed, a concussion may place an
athlete at risk of developing second impact syndrome-a potentially fatal injury
that occurs when an athlete sustains a second head injury before a previous head
injury has completely healed.
What are the signs/symptoms of a concussion?
Concussion symptoms may include the following:
- Balance problems
- Difficulty communicating, concentrating
- Dizziness
- Drowsiness
- Fatigue
- Feeling emotional
- Feeling mentally foggy
- Headache
- Irritability
- Memory difficulties
- Nausea
- Nervousness
- Numbness or tingling
- Sadness
- Sensitivity to light or noise
- Sleeping more than usual or difficulty falling asleep
- Visual problems - blurry or double vision
- Vomiting
Concussion First Aid
If you suffer any head injury, stop activity and seek medical attention. Even
if you think it’s a mild bump on the head, it could turn into something serious
if you return to sports. According to researcher Mark Lowell, allowing an
athlete to return to play too early after any head injury increases their chance
of more serious brain injury. Because signs of a mild concussion -- confusion,
disorientation and memory loss --may disappear within minutes and may not be
reported by the athlete, athletes are too often allowed to continue playing or
return to a game before their brain has had adequate time to heal.
Recent studies on the cumulative effects of concussions in high school
athletes have shown that even mild concussions can result in serious long-term
problems, particularly if an athlete is allowed to return to play too early, or
has a history of concussions or other head injuries.
Deciding when an athlete should return to sports after a concussion remains a
matter of controversy within the medical community. However, various research
projects continue to learn more about concussion assessment and evaluation.
|
According to researcher Mark Lowell, allowing an athlete to return to play
too early increases their chance of more serious brain injury. Given that
concussions are sustained each season by more than 10 percent of high school
athletes, determining when it is safe for these athletes to return to play is an
important objective. The research conducted by the University has also
demonstrated that a history of concussions can cause long-term memory loss and
other problems. According to Dr. Michael Collins, "the study indicates for the
first time in the high school athlete population that prior concussions may
indeed lower the threshold for subsequent concussion injury and increase symptom
severity in even seemingly mild subsequent concussions." Researchers found that
athletes with three or more concussions were nine times more likely to suffer
more severe concussion symptoms (e.g., loss of consciousness and memory) than
players with no prior history of concussion.
The new recommendations, published in 2009 in The British Journal of Sports
Medicine, say any athlete, 18 and under, who may have sustained a concussion
during sports should not be allowed to return to activity the same day. The
group's previous recommendation allowed the athlete to return to activity if
cleared by a doctor or certified athletic trainer. The neurologists now believe
it's too difficult to make an immediate determination of the seriousness of head
injuries which makes it too dangerous for continued play to be considered safe.
This change is stirring up debate among other experts. While many believe this
will help prevent serious, life-threatening injuries in youth sports, some
believe the new guideline will result in more kids hiding their head injury for
fear of being pulled from the game.
| Arguments for "not wearing a helmet
with snow sports" |
 |
Various reasons have been put forward to explain the still
relatively low uptake of helmets on most slopes around the globe.
Leaving aside issues such as cost and availability, (neither of
which should be issues these days) here are some responses to a few
of these concerns: |
1. "Helmets predispose the neck to a greater risk of injury"
A common anti-helmet argument has been the concern that wearing a helmet may
predispose the wearer to a greater risk of injury to the neck. The logic is that
the increased weight of the helmet places the neck under increased strain in the
event of an accident. Thankfully, the issue has been examined in both the
laboratory and also out in the field. Computer simulation data presented at the
17th ISSS meeting concluded that wearing a helmet did not place additional
stress on the neck. More recently, in May 2010 Brent Hagel and colleagues
published the results of a 10 year case-control study looking specifically at
this issue, even subdividing the risk between adults and children. They found no
evidence that wearing a helmet increased the risk of a neck injury whilst skiing
or snowboarding.
2. "Helmets interfere with your vision, especially peripheral vision"
Once again, this concern has been studied and there is no evidence that
wearing a helmet does interfere with the visual field of skiers or snowboarders.
In conclusion...
There is good evidence to indicate that a helmet will protect you against many
of the common injuries that the head is susceptible to when on the slopes.
They are especially important for children, who run a higher generic risk of
snow sport injury. Helmets seem to have their most protective effect in
incidents involving low speed impacts (below 15 mph) and for falls leading to
blows to the head on the snow surface.
| There is no evidence to date that
helmets predispose the wearer to a higher risk of neck injury,
causes injury to others or restrict vision, hearing or general
sensory awareness. |
 |
Finally, be aware that there is no conclusive scientific evidence that
helmets reduce the risk of death in the event of a high speed collision with
another object. Wearing a helmet does not make you invincible and may not offer
you full protection if you have a high speed impact - so go careful, especially
if there are trees on or near the area you are using. |